Using wastewater to track the COVID-19 pandemic
EPFL researchers, working in association with the Swiss Federal Institute of Aquatic Science and Technology (Eawag), have developed a method for detecting the coronavirus in wastewater samples. Their method has been tested successfully on samples collected during the first phase of the pandemic, paving the way to an early-stage warning system.
Scientists around the world are studying the coronavirus (SARS-CoV-2) from many different perspectives in an effort to better understand how it infects the body and spreads from person to person. The goal is to find therapies for neutralizing and eliminating it. One approach being taken by researchers at EPFL and Eawag – until drug treatments and a vaccine are developed – is to analyze wastewater samples so that health officials can detect the virus before the disease is diagnosed clinically. “Our study looks at how we can detect the virus in wastewater and measure its concentration before people start developing clinical symptoms – and to determine how much time before,” says Tamar Kohn, head of EPFL’s Environmental Chemistry Laboratory.
Thanks to Christoph Ort at Eawag’s Urban Water Management Department and Tim Julian at Eawag’s Environmental Microbiology Department, the researchers pulled off a major feat in showing that the coronavirus can be detected and measured in wastewater in a matter of weeks. The researchers analyzed samples from Lausanne, Zurich and Lugano – including samples from Zurich and Lugano that were collected in February 2020 when the first cases were recorded in Switzerland.
“As a specialist in environmental epidemiology, I was ready to work on the pandemic when it first arrived in Italy,” says Xavier Fernandez Cassi at the EPFL’s Environmental Chemistry Laboratory. “It was clear to me that the virus would spread to Switzerland. Given how interlinked countries are today, I would’ve been surprised if it didn’t.”
The researchers found traces of the virus in all the samples they collected. While concentrations in the more recent samples were so high that it was fairly easy to measure them, this was not true for the samples from February 2020. “We didn’t expect to find a signal in wastewater from Lugano – where only one case had been identified at that point – and from Zurich, where only six had been identified,” says Kohn. His team specializes in developing new wastewater treatment methods. Working with colleagues at Eawag, they collected samples from nine wastewater treatment plants in Ticino, two in Zurich and one in Lausanne, corresponding to a total of around 800,000 city residents.
The potential ramifications of this study are so important that Cassi and Marie-Hélène Corre, another LCE biologist, received special authorization to work at their EPFL lab during the lockdown. They were particularly efficient in conducting their experiments since almost nobody else was using the testing equipment in spring 2020, as the campus was nearly deserted. But the researchers had to be extra careful because the coronavirus – even though it comes from a known viral family – is nevertheless a zoonotic virus. “The main characteristic of this virus is that it has envelope – its viral capsid is enveloped in a biological membrane,” says Corre. “The seasonal flu virus and HIV also have envelopes.”
«With samples from 20 large treatment plants distributed across Switzerland, we could monitor wastewater from around 2.5 million people.»
Goal: early warning system
The samples collected since the first cases of COVID-19 were reported in Switzerland are valuable archives. However, the main goal of this study is not to retrace the past but to develop an early warning system. Ort says: “With samples from 20 large treatment plants distributed across Switzerland, we could monitor wastewater from around 2.5 million people.” If the samples are analyzed rapidly, we could probably detect a resurgence of infections earlier than with diagnostic tests – about a week earlier – especially during the period when the lockdown is being lifted.
Ort has long been concerned with wastewater-based epidemiology, previously focusing on comparisons of drug use across Europe. “Wastewater doesn’t lie – it reflects what has been excreted by a population within a few hours,” he says. The research team has drawn on their established contacts with local government agencies and wastewater treatment plants.
Tracking infection trends, not absolute case numbers
Since the researchers were able to successfully detect low viral concentrations at the early stage of the COVID-19 outbreak in Switzerland, they should be able to reconstruct the infection curve. However, they won’t be able to calculate the exact number of infections using these data, since there is too much variation in how much of the virus each patient sheds.
What will be important to track, however, is the trend. For example, using samples collected in Lausanne in March and April 2020, the researchers were able to roughly trace the increase in the wastewater concentration of SARS-CoV-2. Kohn estimates that the concentration rose by a factor of between ten and a hundred.
Despite the researchers’ initial success, they still need to further improve their method. For example, they don’t yet know what percentage of a patient’s viral load is captured when the RNA is extracted after a number of other steps (filtration and centrifugation). There is also much uncertainty in the subsequent selective amplification process for the target sequence. Only when the amount of uncertainty is reduced will they be able to draw robust conclusions about viral concentrations in the original samples.